Talk:DC Comics
(make sense?) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I think it makes sense to have this article on DC Comics. The company appeared - or was referred to - in at least two stories. "The Last Earth Prime" story, with Julie Shwartz' and possibly the tale where Curt Swan meets Superman. -- [[User:Macduff|Macduff]] 22:42, 15 September 2007 (EDT) | I think it makes sense to have this article on DC Comics. The company appeared - or was referred to - in at least two stories. "The Last Earth Prime" story, with Julie Shwartz' and possibly the tale where Curt Swan meets Superman. -- [[User:Macduff|Macduff]] 22:42, 15 September 2007 (EDT) | ||
| + | |||
| + | __________________________________________________________________________________ | ||
| + | |||
| + | I disagree with the entry for the following reasons: | ||
| + | |||
| + | 1. I have no problem with non-canonical references being included (spelled out in full) if the character later appeared in canonical works. | ||
| + | |||
| + | 2. If we allow references to non-canonical stories, why not let in references to all DC, including Justice League etc. Tons of Justice League is referenced in Superman stories. I still think Black Lightning was a mistake, based on preferences not on guidelines. | ||
| + | |||
| + | 3. There are hundreds of 70s and 80s canonical stories not included in Supermanica. I keep thinking that the Bronze Age fans could start on those rather than favorite DC comics from the time period. I don't even like the Bronze Age but I've been trying to enter the stories. | ||
| + | |||
| + | I still think that Supermanica has many hundreds of references to go before entries based on non-canonical sources should be included. | ||
| + | - MatterEaterLad | ||
Revision as of 23:20, 15 September 2007
I think it makes sense to have this article on DC Comics. The company appeared - or was referred to - in at least two stories. "The Last Earth Prime" story, with Julie Shwartz' and possibly the tale where Curt Swan meets Superman. -- Macduff 22:42, 15 September 2007 (EDT)
__________________________________________________________________________________
I disagree with the entry for the following reasons:
1. I have no problem with non-canonical references being included (spelled out in full) if the character later appeared in canonical works.
2. If we allow references to non-canonical stories, why not let in references to all DC, including Justice League etc. Tons of Justice League is referenced in Superman stories. I still think Black Lightning was a mistake, based on preferences not on guidelines.
3. There are hundreds of 70s and 80s canonical stories not included in Supermanica. I keep thinking that the Bronze Age fans could start on those rather than favorite DC comics from the time period. I don't even like the Bronze Age but I've been trying to enter the stories.
I still think that Supermanica has many hundreds of references to go before entries based on non-canonical sources should be included. - MatterEaterLad
